SDA vs EBITDA: Which Metric Matters Most for Your Business Purchase?

When it comes to valuing a business, two financial metrics often take center stage: Seller’s Discretionary Earnings (SDE) and Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation, and Amortization (EBITDA). Both metrics serve as critical tools for understanding a company’s profitability, but they are used in different contexts and for different types of businesses. In this article I’ll explain the key differences, applications, and calculations of SDE and EBITDA to help you navigate the complex world of business valuation.

What is SDE?

Seller’s Discretionary Earnings (SDE) is a comprehensive financial metric used to evaluate the total financial benefit a business owner derives from their enterprise. This metric is particularly valuable for small, owner-operated businesses, where the owner’s personal involvement and discretionary spending significantly influence the company’s financial performance. By including various financial components like net income, the owner’s salary, discretionary expenses, and one-time costs, SDE provides a clear and personalized snapshot of the financial gains a potential buyer can expect if they take over the business.

Key Components of SDE

• Net Income: The profit left after deducting all expenses from revenue.
• Owner’s Salary: The compensation drawn by the owner, whether as a salary or distribution.
• Discretionary Expenses: Personal or non-essential business expenses like travel or health club memberships.
• Non-Cash Expenses: Depreciation and amortization, which don’t require cash outlays.
• Non-Recurring Expenses: One-time costs such as legal fees for a lawsuit or marketing expenses for a specific campaign.

SDE Formula

The basic formula for calculating SDE is:

SDE=NetIncome+Owner’sSalary+DiscretionaryExpenses+Non−CashExpenses+Non−RecurringExpenses

Example of SDE Calculation

Let’s consider a small business with the following financial data:

• Net Income: $300,000
• Owner’s Salary: $120,000
• Discretionary Expenses: $15,000
• Non-Cash Expenses (Depreciation and Amortization): $10,000
• Non-Recurring Expenses: $20,000

Using the formula:

SDE=300,000+120,000+15,000+10,000+20,000=465,000

In this case, the SDE of $465,000 reflects the owner’s total financial benefit.

What is EBITDA?

Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation, and Amortization (EBITDA) is a financial metric that focuses exclusively on a company’s operational profitability. Unlike SDE, EBITDA excludes non-operational factors like owner’s compensation, discretionary spending, and one-time costs, making it a standardized and widely accepted measure for comparing businesses across industries. It’s particularly useful for larger companies or those preparing for mergers and acquisitions, as it isolates the performance of core operations.

Key Components of EBITDA

• Net Income: The total earnings after expenses.
• Interest: Added back to remove the impact of financing decisions.
• Taxes: Excluded to focus on operational performance.
• Depreciation and Amortization: Non-cash accounting charges added back to net income.

EBITDA Formula

The formula for EBITDA is:

EBITDA=NetIncome+Interest+Taxes+Depreciation+Amortization

Example of EBITDA Calculation

Consider a mid-sized company with the following data:

• Net Income: $500,000
• Interest: $25,000
• Taxes: $50,000
• Depreciation: $15,000
• Amortization: $10,000

Using the formula:

EBITDA=500,000+25,000+50,000+15,000+10,000=600,000

This EBITDA of $600,000 reflects the company’s operational earnings.

Key Differences Between SDE and EBITDA

If you’re evaluating a business for acquisition, understanding whether to focus on Seller’s Discretionary Earnings (SDE) or Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation, and Amortization (EBITDA) is critical to making an informed decision. These metrics serve different purposes and are tailored to businesses of varying sizes and operational structures. This section delves deeply into the differences between SDE and EBITDA, their applications, and their impact on valuation.

Scope and Applicability

SDE and EBITDA are not one-size-fits-all metrics. They are suited to different business models, primarily based on company size and ownership structure.

• SDE is primarily used for small, owner-operated businesses. These businesses typically have a single owner who is heavily involved in daily operations. For such enterprises, the owner’s compensation and discretionary expenses significantly impact the company’s financial performance. SDE provides a comprehensive picture of the total financial benefit an owner derives from the business, making it the go-to metric for valuing smaller companies.
• EBITDA  is typically the preferred metric for evaluating larger businesses, especially in mergers and acquisitions (M&A). It focuses on operational profitability and excludes owner-specific adjustments, giving you a clearer picture of how the business performs independently of its current management structure. EBITDA provides a standardized measure of operational profitability, making it easier to compare businesses across industries or regions.

Examples:

1. A family-owned bakery where the owner draws a salary and uses company funds for discretionary expenses like a company car is best evaluated using SDE.
2. A mid-sized manufacturing firm with multiple stakeholders and a professional management team would use EBITDA to showcase its operational efficiency.

Expense Inclusions

One of the primary differences between SDE and EBITDA lies in the types of expenses included or excluded.

• SDE includes the owner’s salary, benefits, and discretionary expenses, along with non-cash expenses like depreciation and amortization. It also accounts for non-recurring expenses, such as legal fees for a one-time lawsuit or costs associated with a failed marketing campaign. SDE generally adds back the owner’s total financial benefit, whether via salary, distributions, or perks. If multiple owners exist, adjustments may be more complex to reflect each person’s discretionary share. By including these adjustments, SDE provides a more personalized view of cash flow for owner-operated businesses.
• EBITDA, on the other hand, focuses solely on operational earnings. It excludes non-operating expenses such as interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization. This allows stakeholders to evaluate the company’s core profitability without the influence of financing decisions or accounting practices.

Complexity of Calculation

The complexity of calculating these metrics also sets them apart.

• SDE calculations are more intricate because they involve adjusting for discretionary and non-recurring expenses. For example, if the owner uses the business to pay for personal travel or family health insurance, these costs must be added back to the net income. Additionally, any extraordinary one-time costs, like the expense of defending a lawsuit or restructuring the business, are also considered.
• EBITDA, by contrast, is simpler and more standardized. It involves adding back interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization to the net income. The straightforward nature of EBITDA makes it a preferred metric for large businesses with complex financial structures.

Choosing the Right Metric: SDE vs EBITDA

The decision to use Seller’s Discretionary Earnings (SDE) or Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation, and Amortization (EBITDA) as a valuation metric is not arbitrary. It depends on several critical factors, including the size and nature of the business, the industry it operates in, and the purpose of the valuation. Each metric provides a distinct perspective on financial performance, making it essential to understand when and why each is appropriate.

When to Use SDE

SDE is primarily tailored for smaller, owner-operated businesses. This metric accounts for the total financial benefit the owner derives from the company, making it a suitable choice in scenarios where the owner’s involvement is deeply intertwined with the business’s operations.

For Small Businesses Generating Less Than $1 Million in Annual Revenue

SDE is most commonly used for small businesses with limited revenue streams. These businesses often operate with the owner playing a central role in management, decision-making, and daily operations. By including the owner’s compensation and discretionary expenses, SDE offers a realistic view of the financial benefits available to the owner. SDE is typically best if the owner’s personal involvement and discretionary expenses strongly impact profits, whereas EBITDA is standard when operations are more independent from the owner, regardless of revenue size.

When the Owner’s Involvement in Operations Influences Profitability

In owner-operated businesses, the owner’s efforts directly impact the company’s success. For example, an owner might handle multiple roles such as marketing, sales, and customer service, which would otherwise require hiring additional staff. SDE captures this dynamic by including the owner’s salary, benefits, and other discretionary spending. This makes SDE particularly valuable when the potential buyer is an individual planning to assume a similar hands-on role.

To Provide a Comprehensive View of Cash Flow

As a prospective buyer, SDE offers you a complete picture of the financial benefits you can expect to gain from the business, including discretionary expenses that may not be part of its ongoing operations. It accounts for discretionary expenses such as travel, personal vehicles, or family health insurance, which are often paid through the business. This transparency is crucial for buyers seeking to understand the full earning potential of the company.

Example Use Case

A small restaurant where the owner actively manages operations, including hiring staff, managing inventory, and overseeing customer relations, would use SDE to reflect the owner’s financial benefit. By including discretionary and non-operational expenses, SDE presents an accurate valuation.

When to Use EBITDA

EBITDA, in contrast, is the preferred metric for larger companies, particularly those with revenues exceeding $1 million. Its focus on operational profitability makes it a critical tool for analyzing the financial health of businesses that operate independently of owner influence.

For Larger Businesses with Annual Revenues Exceeding $1 Million

EBITDA is designed for larger companies where the owner’s personal involvement is minimal. These businesses often have professional management teams and structured operational frameworks, making operational profitability the key focus. EBITDA excludes discretionary expenses and owner compensation, providing a cleaner, standardized measure of earnings.

To Focus on Operational Profitability

Unlike SDE, EBITDA removes non-operational costs such as interest, taxes, and depreciation. This allows stakeholders to evaluate the company’s core performance without distractions from financing strategies or accounting practices. For example, a manufacturing company’s EBITDA might reflect its efficiency in production and operational processes, making it a useful tool for assessing scalability and growth potential.

For Comparability Across Industries or Companies

EBITDA’s standardized nature makes it ideal for comparing businesses within the same industry or across different sectors. This is particularly important in mergers and acquisitions (M&A), where potential buyers need a consistent metric to evaluate multiple opportunities. By focusing solely on operational earnings, EBITDA ensures a level playing field for comparisons.

Example Use Case

A mid-sized software development firm with multiple stakeholders, significant capital investments, and plans for expansion would use EBITDA. This metric would highlight its operational efficiency and scalability, making it more attractive to institutional investors or private equity firms.

Impact on Business Valuation

The choice between SDE and EBITDA can significantly influence a business’s valuation, as the two metrics often yield different results.

SDE Valuation

SDE is often multiplied by a factor (commonly 1x to 4x) to determine the business’s valuation. But real-world multiples can fall outside these ranges, depending on industry trends, competition, and each company’s specific risk and growth profile.

Example: a small retail store with an SDE of $150,000 might be valued at 2.5x SDE, resulting in a valuation of $375,000.

Factors That Affect SDE Multiples:

1. Industry Norms: Some industries command higher multiples due to their stability or growth potential.
2. Economic Conditions: A booming economy might lead to higher multiples, while a recession could lower them.
3. Owner Dependency: Businesses heavily reliant on the owner might receive lower multiples.

EBITDA Valuation

EBITDA is typically multiplied by a higher factor (ranging from 3x to 10x) due to its focus on operational profitability and scalability. However, real-world multiples for EBITDA can also deviate from typical ranges, influenced by industry dynamics, market competition, and the unique risk and growth characteristics of each company.

Example: a manufacturing company with an EBITDA of $1 million might be valued at 5x EBITDA, resulting in a valuation of $5 million.

Factors That Affect EBITDA Multiples:

1. Operational Efficiency: Businesses with streamlined operations often command higher multiples.
2. Growth Potential: Companies with strong growth prospects are more attractive to investors.
3. Market Trends: Industries experiencing high demand often see higher multiples.

Conclusion

It’s so important to understand the differences between SDE and EBITDA when you’re valuing a business because each metric is suited to different types of businesses and purposes. SDE shines in small, owner-operated businesses, where the owner’s involvement and discretionary expenses play a major role in profitability. In contrast, EBITDA focuses on operational efficiency, making it ideal for larger companies or those preparing for mergers and acquisitions.

Choosing the right metric depends on factors like business size, industry, and valuation goals. By clearly defining what each metric reveals about a business’s financial health, owners and buyers can make more informed decisions. Whether you’re preparing to sell a business or assessing its value, understanding how and when to use SDE or EBITDA ensures you’re presenting the most accurate financial picture possible.

FAQs